Karina faced scapegoating when Jungkook supporters deflected criticism by targeting her with political accusations. These claims, lacking evidence, led to a toxic blame game between BTS and aespa fans. The controversy revealed how manipulated narratives and fandom power can distort public perception.
Jungkook Cap Sparks Political Controversy
During rehearsals for j-hope’s concert “HOPE ON THE STAGE FINAL”, BTS member Jungkook was spotted wearing a cap that read “MAKE TOKYO GREAT AGAIN.” Korean leftist circles quickly claimed, without evidence, that this phrase was used by Japanese far-right groups. However, the Japanese fashion brand BASICKS, which made the cap, stated on Instagram that the design had no political intent. According to them, the phrase symbolized their hope for Tokyo’s fashion scene to thrive again.
Karina Used as a Tool for Scapegoating by Jungkook Supporters
As leftist criticism persisted, Jungkook’s fans began deflecting attention toward Karina from aespa. They claimed Karina once wore a red jacket with the number 2, which they argued matched the color and symbolism of South Korea’s conservative party. Using that logic, they made the absurd claim that Karina supported American conservatism, drawing an unwarranted parallel with MAGA. Some even argued Jungkook’s apology was more sincere than Karina’s, trying to downplay his situation. This tactic clearly aimed to shift the focus from Jungkook’s hat by dragging Karina into the controversy.
Karina Becomes a Scapegoat in a Political Blame Game
Karina became a scapegoat simply because Jungkook’s fans needed someone to redirect criticism. Their accusations were groundless and far-fetched. Instead of offering a clear explanation for Jungkook’s cap, they chose to attack Karina and change the subject.
aespa Fans Strike Back with MAGA Parody Accusations
In response, aespa fans dug up an old photo of BTS member RM wearing a cap with the phrase “MAKE COMEDY GREAT AGAIN.” They claimed this also referenced MAGA ideology. BTS fans hit back by sharing a similar photo of aespa’s Giselle wearing the same cap. However, the phrase is actually a parody, mocking MAGA rather than supporting it. Despite this, the situation escalated due to false claims and manipulated narratives.
aespa Bears the Consequences Despite Unfounded Allegations
As the issue grew, aespa again bore the brunt of the backlash. Given BTS’s massive fandom, even a small number targeting aespa caused significant ripple effects. Terms like “MAGASELLL” and “MAGARINA” started circulating on social media. Although they didn’t spread widely due to lack of evidence, this incident showed how a few malicious voices can still do harm. The scale of BTS’s fandom amplified even minor attacks into something damaging.
Even theqoo Users Recognize Scapegoating Karina Was Unjustified
When this issue reached the Korean online forum theqoo, reactions showed a stark contrast. Known for its left-leaning views and past hostility toward Karina, the forum surprisingly found little fault with Giselle’s cap. However, the same community had previously ignored verbal harassment against Karina while harshly criticizing her perceived political stance. Even theqoo, despite its usual bias, considered the attack on Giselle too far-fetched to accept. This double standard reveals how weak the accusations were, as even Karina’s harshest critics refused to support them.
Karina Incident Shows How Scapegoating Replaces Rational Discussion
Ultimately, these controversies stem from baseless conspiracy theories and manufactured outrage. In any democracy, Karina’s political preferences should not matter. Jungkook’s hat, as confirmed, had no ties to Japanese far-right politics. These are stories created by those who thrive on drama and manipulation. Korean netizens often react emotionally and fall for provocations too easily. There is a strong need for more reasoned and logical public discourse in Korean online culture.

Thank you so much for reading this post! I’d love to hear your thoughts, so feel free to share them in the comments!
Why are Jungkook’s fans attacking Karina for no reason? It’s weird how wearing a “MAKE TOKYO GREAT AGAIN” cap in Korea is even an issue. Things that are no big deal in other countries are treated like huge problems here in Korea.